What's a Good Return for Traders?
Updated: Oct 18
People ask me what a good return for traders is more than almost anything else, and I've never loved my own answer. I usually give a number and then spend ten minutes taking it back. I think the question starts at the wrong end.
Most people pick the number first. They see a screenshot of someone up 40% in a month, decide 20% sounds reasonable for them, and then work backward to whatever risk gets them there. That's how you end up risking 8% a trade on a $5,000 account and calling it a strategy. The return was the goal, the risk was whatever it took, and the account is gone by March.

For scale: the S&P 500 has averaged around 10% a year over the long run. A fund manager who does 20% a year for a decade gets profiled in magazines. So when a course pitches 20% a month as the normal outcome, that's a claim the best-funded investors on the planet can't back up, made by someone selling you a PDF.
Retail traders do have real advantages. You're not moving billions, you can sit in cash for a week without anyone asking why, and on a funded account you're trading capital you didn't put up. None of that turns 20% a month into a plan.

A good return for traders comes from edge times risk
You don't get to pick your monthly return. It falls out of three numbers you already have, or should have: how many trades you take, what each trade is worth on average, and how much you risk per trade.
The average value of a trade is your expectancy, measured in R, where 1R is whatever you risked. Win 50% of the time, make 2R on winners, lose 1R on losers, and each trade is worth 0.5R: (0.5 × 2) − (0.5 × 1) = 0.5R.
Now multiply. Ten trades a month at 0.5R is 5R. At 1% risk per trade that's about 5% for the month. At 2% risk, about 10%.

0.5R is a strong edge, though. Plenty of profitable traders run closer to 0.2R or 0.3R. Ten trades at 0.25R and 1% risk is 2.5% a month, and that's a trader who is genuinely good at this.
Having no edge at all is easier than people think. Win 40% of the time with 1.5R winners and your expectancy is (0.4 × 1.5) − (0.6 × 1) = 0. You can execute that flawlessly for a year and finish exactly where you started, minus spreads and commissions. Which is to say, down.
If you have 30 or more trades logged, run them through the Trade Journal Stats Calculator. It pulls your win rate, profit factor, and expectancy from the same log.
If you want them one at a time, there's the Win Rate Calculator, Profit Factor Calculator, Expectancy Calculator, and R-Multiple Calculator. Your expectancy tells you more about your realistic return than any blog post, this one included.
What a monthly return compounds into
Run a monthly number out for twelve months with the gains reinvested and the fantasy numbers get exposed fast.
Monthly return | After 12 months | $10,000 becomes |
1% | +12.7% | $11,268 |
2.5% | +34.5% | $13,449 |
5% | +79.6% | $17,959 |
10% | +213.8% | $31,384 |
15% | +435.0% | $53,503 |
That 15% row turns ten grand into more than fifty in a year. Anyone who could do that reliably would not need your $97 a month for their signal group. Even 5% a month compounded is close to 80% a year, roughly triple what a top fund would call a great year. It happens. The people who keep it up for years are rare enough that you'd know their names.
Put your own expected monthly number into the Compounding Calculator and look at the three-year figure. If it looks absurd, your monthly assumption is too high.

Same strategy, very different traders
Two traders, both with $25,000, same setups, same 50% win rate. One risks 1% per trade, which is $250. The other risks 5%, which is $1,250. In a good month the second one posts five times the return and looks like a genius on Instagram.
Then the losing streak shows up. Over 200 trades at a 50% win rate, a run of seven or eight losses in a row is roughly what you should expect, so plan for it.
Risk per trade | First loss | Balance after 8 straight losses | Total lost | Gain needed to get back to $25,000 |
1% | $250 | $23,069 | $1,931 | +8.4% |
2% | $500 | $21,269 | $3,731 | +17.5% |
5% | $1,250 | $16,586 | $8,414 | +50.7% |
10% | $2,500 | $10,762 | $14,238 | +132.3% |
Each loss is a percentage of what's left, so the dollar risk shrinks a little as the balance drops. The 1% trader's eighth loss is $233, not $250.
The 1% trader is down $1,931 and needs a couple of decent weeks. The 5% trader is down $8,414 and has to make 50% on a $16,586 account just to get back to where she started, and the pressure to size up and "get it back" is now enormous. The 10% trader lost more than half her account in eight trades. She's done, she just doesn't know it yet.
The hole gets deeper faster than it looks because you're climbing out on a smaller balance. Down 10% needs 11% back. Down 20% needs 25%. Down 30% needs 43%. Down 50% needs 100%.

Same example but with percentages
Two traders, both with $10,000, same setups, same 50% win rate. One risks 1% per trade. The other risks 5%. In a good month the second one posts five times the return and looks like a genius on Instagram.
Then the losing streak shows up. Over 200 trades at a 50% win rate, a run of seven or eight losses in a row is roughly what you should expect, so plan for it.
Risk per trade | After 8 straight losses | Gain needed to get back to even |
1% | −7.7% | +8.4% |
2% | −14.9% | +17.5% |
5% | −33.7% | +50.7% |
10% | −57.0% | +132.3% |
The 1% trader needs a couple of decent weeks. The 5% trader needs to make 50% on a smaller account just to be where she started, and the pressure to size up and "get it back" is now enormous. The 10% trader is done, she just doesn't know it yet.
The hole gets deeper faster than it looks because you're climbing out on a smaller balance. Down 10% needs 11% back. Down 20% needs 25%. Down 30% needs 43%. Down 50% needs 100%.
So a monthly return tells you almost nothing until you know the risk behind it. A 5% month at 1% risk per trade is a real result. A 20% month at 10% risk per trade is one bad week waiting to happen. The Account Growth Calculator lets you run a losing streak through your own risk percentage before the market does it for you.
How I set targets: ticks per week, not percent per month
I've been trading futures lately, so I think in ticks. My target is 60 to 90 ticks a week, risking 1 to 2% of the account per trade. Forex traders can do the same thing in pips. A weekly target in ticks or pips keeps my attention on execution, and the percentage takes care of itself.
One week from February this year, the 10th through the 17th: 175 trades, about 32 a day, each sitting in the market around five minutes. 73.7% were winners. The average winner was 1.58 times the average loser, the profit factor came out just under 5, and the average trade was worth about 0.9R.

That's a hot week, and the parts I'd point you to are the ugly ones. Five losses in a row. A $2,620 drawdown. One single loser of $1,320. And close to four days without a new equity high, trading below my best balance with no way of knowing yet whether the edge had gone. I didn't size up to get it back. Same size, same rules, and the week finished where the numbers said it should.
The long/short split is worth a look too. My longs had winners about 1.8 times the size of my losers. My shorts won more often, 77.8% of the time, but their winners were barely bigger than their losers, a 1.05 ratio. If I'd only looked at win rate, I'd have thought the shorts were my better side.
I don't plan around weeks like that. A profit factor near 5 means the market cooperated, and the next week it might not.
I also have a dollar figure for a normal good day and a much bigger one for a great day. The great day isn't the target. The moment I start aiming for it, my size creeps up and my stops get sloppy, and that's how a great week turns into a red one.
On a personal account I let the gains compound. On a funded account I don't, and that changes how I think about what a good month even is.
Funded accounts change the math
On a prop firm account, compounding mostly doesn't apply. The firm caps your size, and the account doesn't grow just because you had a good month. So the job is different: take profits out on a schedule and leave a buffer above the drawdown limit so one bad day can't end the account.
Your real account is the drawdown allowance, not the headline balance. Say a firm gives you a $50,000 account with a $2,500 max drawdown. Risking 1% of $50,000 is $500 a trade, which is 20% of the money you can actually lose. Five losers in a row and you're shopping for a new evaluation. At $125 a trade, eight straight losses cost $1,000 and you're still standing with $1,500 of cushion. Whatever risk you choose, know how many losses in a row it takes to fail the account before you place the first trade.

This is also why "10% a month" from a funded trader and "20% a year" from a fund aren't the same kind of number. The funded trader's 10% is measured on capital she didn't put up and can't compound. Her actual mo
ney at risk is the evaluation fee and the drawdown cushion. Comparing the two is like comparing a commission check to a salary.
Steady, moderate payouts tend to go smoother than one giant one. Prop firms are businesses with their own risk desks, many have consistency rules that limit how much of your profit can come from a single day, and a record that looks steady raises fewer questions at payout time. Read your firm's payout and consistency rules before you need them, not the day you request a withdrawal.
What I keep chewing on is whether "what's a good return" is even a fair question before someone has 50 trades logged. Without those, any number I give is a guess about a trader who doesn't exist yet. Maybe the honest answer is to go find out what your own trades are worth, then come back and ask me. I'm not sure that would get as many clicks.

Quick FAQ
What is a good monthly return for a trader? For a consistent trader risking around 1% per trade, roughly 1% to 5% a month is a strong result. Your own realistic number comes from your expectancy, how many trades you take, and your risk per trade.
What annual return do professional fund managers consider good? Around 20% to 30% a year is considered excellent, against a long-run S&P 500 average of roughly 10% a year.
Is a high monthly return a good sign? Only if you know the risk behind it. A big month built on 5% to 10% risk per trade usually ends in a drawdown the account can't recover from.
Do funded traders compound their returns? Usually not. Size is capped by the firm, so most funded traders withdraw profits on a schedule and keep a buffer above the drawdown limit.
Educational purposes only. Forex trading involves substantial risk. Return figures in this post are illustrative math, not projections or promises, and prop firm rules vary by firm, so read your own firm's terms.

.png)





Comments